Using dental amalgam shall be banned within the European Union from January 2025 – we check out the well being dangers related to dental amalgam, why it’s being banned, and the affect this might have on the UK dental occupation.
Amalgam ban: the important thing info
In January of this yr (2024), the European Parliament voted to ban dental amalgam. In consequence, a complete phase-out of the filling materials will happen within the European Union (EU) from 1 January 2025.
The ban, which comes into impact 5 years sooner than anticipated, goals to guard each human well being and the surroundings from the dangerous results of mercury.
In dentistry, the use and export of amalgam shall be prohibited, with exceptions solely ‘for specific medical needs and when deemed strictly necessary by a medical practitioner’.
Nonetheless, nations that want extra time to adapt their healthcare programs to the ban will obtain an extension, permitting them to proceed utilizing and importing dental amalgam till 30 June 2026.
Amalgam use in UK dentistry
Amalgam has been utilized in dentistry as a filling materials for over 175 years. The fabric is a mix of metals – 50% liquid mercury and 50% powdered alloy composed of silver, tin and copper.
Its use was first launched as a filling materials in France and Britain within the early 1800s, with America following go well with within the 1830s, although historians have doubtlessly traced its use way back to 659 AD. Following its introduction, it shortly turned essentially the most extensively used filling materials.
Controversy over the security of dental amalgam has existed from the outset, nevertheless. When the American Society of Dental Surgeons shaped in 1840, its members needed to pledge to by no means use the filling materials because of mercury toxicity.
At the moment, dental amalgam stays the most typical materials for NHS everlasting fillings throughout the UK. However its use comes with agency rules. Article 10 of the European Union Regulation 2017/852 states:
Dental amalgam should solely be utilized in pre-dosed encapsulated type. Using mercury in bulk type by dental practitioners is prohibited
Dental amalgam should not be used for the dental therapy of deciduous enamel of youngsters below 15 years, or for pregnant or breastfeeding ladies. That is besides when deemed strictly needed by the dental practitioner primarily based on the affected person’s particular medical wants
Dental practices should be outfitted with an amalgam separator. All separators should retain not less than 95% of amalgam particles.
Dental amalgam versus composite fillings
For over 100 years, dental amalgam has been the most well-liked filling materials due to its energy, sturdiness and low price. At the moment, nevertheless, tooth-coloured restorative supplies reminiscent of composite are quickly gaining recognition because of their aesthetic attraction.
The British Dental Trade Affiliation (BDIA) outlines the next benefits and downsides of the filling supplies.
Amalgam advantagesAmalgam disadvantagesComposite advantagesComposite disadvantagesStrongPoor aestheticsGreat aestheticsRequires bonding agentGood durabilityRequires elimination of wholesome tooth tissue to create sufficient house to carry the fillingMinimal elimination of tooth requiredTime consuming procedureEasy to placeTakes time to setBonds on to toothCan shrink as soon as set, that means decay can develop within the gapsRelatively low costCan corrode over timeHardens instantly with gentle curingHigh price in comparison with amalgamRisk of mercury poisonReasonably durableCan stain and discolour over timeRequires a lining materials to insulate the toothReasonably sturdy
Dealing with dental amalgam within the dental follow
Beforehand, dental amalgam was made in follow by utilizing a pestle and mortar to combine the metals collectively. This course of has now been changed by a dental amalgamator which makes use of vibrations to combine a pre-dosed capsule containing the mercury and powdered alloy.
As a result of excessive mercury content material of dental amalgam, it’s thought-about a hazardous waste. In consequence, there are a number of rules in place for the disposal of dental amalgam waste.
For workers dealing with dental amalgam in follow, small doses over a time period will be dangerous. In consequence, any spillages should be instantly reported, and the producer’s directions should be carefully adopted.
Pete Gibbons, a decontamination specialist, says: ‘Dental amalgam is usually thought-about protected to the broader inhabitants, nevertheless it could actually create some irritations which WHO (the World Well being Group) and the FDI (World Dental Federation) recognise, so there are some precautions to think about.
‘For example, whenever removing amalgam, PPE (personal protective equipment) must be worn at all times. Always dispose of unused cartridges or amalgam waste in a lidded amalgam pot for safe removal. You should also always remove any amalgam from instruments before sterilisation as the particles can build up inside the steriliser.’
Observe rules
NHS England outlines the next rules for dealing with dental amalgam waste in Well being Technical Memorandum 07-01: Secure and sustainable administration of healthcare waste:
Dental practitioners should be sure that all waste is handled appropriately, and that enamel containing amalgam are disposed of as dental amalgam waste. Specialised containers referred to as tooth pots, crown pots and bridge pots could also be used to retailer extracted amalgam-contaminated enamel, crowns and bridges
As a consequence of its distinctive traits, dental amalgam must be handled as its personal waste stream, with separate bins for infectious and non-infectious amalgam
Amalgam waste could also be packed in accordance with the SDS offered by the producer, however the bundle must be marked with UN 2025
Dental amalgam bins should be sealable and created from puncture-resistant inflexible materials and should comprise a mercury suppressant. Bins should be clearly marked as dental amalgam and will characteristic the hazard symbols related to mercury (poisonous, long-term well being hazard and environmental hazard)
If transporting dental amalgam waste, a container licensed for transporting mercury might should be used.
Impression of mercury on well being
The World Well being Group (WHO) states that mercury is poisonous to human well being. In its liquid type, the steel has restricted absorption via pores and skin. However in vapour type, it turns into extraordinarily poisonous as absorption via lungs can injury the immune system. Additionally it is notably harmful to foetuses.
In accordance with WHO, the well being impacts of mercury embody kidney issues, nervous system injury and pores and skin issues. As well as, the inhalation, ingestion or dermal publicity of mercury can lead to neurological and behavioural issues.
Signs of this may embody:
Tremors
Insomnia
Reminiscence loss
Neuromuscular results
Complications
Cognitive dysfunction
Motor dysfunction.
Sufferers are more than likely to be impacted by mercury through the placement or elimination of dental amalgam. In consequence, except the filling is broken or faulty, it’s safer to depart the fillings in place than take away them.
In accordance with the European Fee, when in shut contact with pores and skin and mucous membranes, mercury may cause allergic pores and skin irritation. Subsequently, dental amalgam fillings can generally lead to irritation of the gums and painful ulcers within the mouth. In some instances, the irritation can happen in different components of the physique, such because the face.
If a affected person is experiencing these signs, elimination of the amalgam filling will often resolve the issue.
Impression of mercury on the surroundings
Steven Mulligan is a dentist and scientific instructor within the Faculty of Medical Dentistry on the College of Sheffield. He has printed numerous works on the environmental impacts of dental supplies and integrating sustainability into oral healthcare.
Right here, Steven discusses how dental amalgam impacts the surroundings…
The primary environmental impacts attributed to amalgam stem from the discharge of mercury into wastewater from its use in dental surgical procedures and from mercury vapour into the environment from crematoria. Amalgam separators take away roughly 95% of amalgam particles from scientific wastewater, and filters are current in crematoria flues to mitigate launched pollution.
We should always recognise that amalgam separators have solely been utilized in some nations for the final thirty years; it turned federal legislation within the USA as late as 2013, and in lots of lower- and middle-income nations, separators usually are not used in any respect. To that finish, the environmental and organic affect of the mercury from dental amalgam stays a persistent worldwide downside.
As such, below the auspices of the Minimata Conference, a worldwide treaty efficient since 2017 which requires signatory nations to scale back mercury launch, amalgam is scheduled to be phased-down till it’s in the end phased-out.
‘The environmental and biological impact of the mercury from dental amalgam remains a persistent worldwide problem’
It must also be recognised that apart from the direct air pollution potential of dental amalgam, the carbon footprint of amalgam manufacturing is larger than various supplies reminiscent of resin-based composite and glass ionomers. As well as, resin-based composite supplies are sturdy long-term restorative choices, additional bolstering requires amalgam’s demise.
Nonetheless, it must also be famous that various supplies have carbon impacts from manufacturing, distribution, use and disposal. The reality is that each one dental supplies and their use have environmental impacts.
Sustainable oral healthcare provision should recognise this via the prevention of illness and provision of high-quality restorative care that’s sturdy and requires fewer replacements. This is only one side of offering extra environmentally sustainable dentistry.
The UK occupation’s response to the dental amalgam ban
Following information of the EU ban, members of the UK dental occupation shared their views on the ruling.
Dentist James Goolnik mentioned: ‘Lastly the European Parliament is banning using amalgam fillings. It has been used as a filling materials since 1826 – a mix of mercury, silver, copper, tin and zinc.
‘Amalgam is a cheap and easy to use filling material, but it is terrible for the body and the environment. This is wonderful news for patients and clinicians.’
He added: ‘I am sorry for NHS dentistry, but it is time to put the patient first by practicing preventive dentistry starting with diet and nutrition and using more biocompatible materials that do not harm the clinical team and the environment.’
Equally, dental therapist Linzy Baker highlighted the failings of dental amalgam as a filling materials. She mentioned: ‘In my daily practice I see a lot of amalgam restorations that are now, after many years, starting to deteriorate. On removal, many have fracture lines within the tooth structure, requiring further destruction to remove. If these are too large, it can change the plan of refilling into something lab-made.’
On the affect of the NHS, she mentioned: ‘There are issues round how the NHS will proceed ought to this materials be faraway from UK NHS practices, as it’s the mostly used posterior filling materials because of price and longevity.
‘The advancements in adhesive materials, to me, negate the longevity argument as, done well, they have also been proven to stand for just as long of which I see the evidence in my daily practice.I, for one, welcome the change and think the benefits outweigh the risks moving forward.’
How will the ban affect UK dentistry?
Presently, dental amalgam is the most typical materials for NHS everlasting fillings within the UK.
In accordance with the British Dental Affiliation (BDA), fillings account for round 1 / 4 of all NHS therapy delivered in England, with amalgam being utilized in one third of those procedures.
In consequence, issues have been raised on the affect of the ban on the commerce and provide of dental amalgam within the UK. This comes at a time when an unbiased investigation into the state of NHS dentistry has discovered it to be ‘in a critical condition’.
In response to the ban announcement, the BDA acknowledged that whereas it helps a phase-down of dental amalgam, the speedy phase-out is neither ‘feasible nor justifiable’.
Eddie Crouch, BDA chair, mentioned: ‘After we are set to lose a key weapon within the therapy of tooth decay all 4 UK governments seem asleep on the wheel.
‘When alternative materials can’t compete, this may add new prices and new uncertainties to practices already on the brink. With out decisive motion this might be the straw that breaks the again of NHS dentistry.’
‘Important restorative materials’
Crouch wrote to the UK’s chief dental officers following information of the ban, saying: ‘I’m writing as soon as once more to hunt your dedication to handle worldwide developments regarding the way forward for dental amalgam, that are prone to considerably have an effect on the supply of dentistry and inhabitants oral well being within the UK.’
He continued: ‘We’re extraordinarily involved in regards to the affect this EU phase-out can have on providers throughout the UK, each instantly below post-Brexit preparations and not directly on account of provide chain collapse in Europe. NHS dentistry is already in precarious state of affairs throughout the UK, with the Nuffield Belief lately warning that the service has more than likely “gone for good”.
‘The lack of a significant restorative materials and its alternative with costlier and time-consuming options is just an extra blow to the monetary viability of NHS dentistry. It’s a specific loss within the context of excessive wants sufferers for whom amalgam stays the most effective therapy possibility.’
When requested how the ban may affect UK dentistry, a Division of Well being and Social Care (DHSC) spokesperson informed Dentistry: ‘We don’t count on the ban on dental amalgam to have an effect on sufferers with the ability to get dental therapy after they want it.
‘Prevention is better than cure, and this government is committed to ensuring good oral health in our future generations.’
Northern Eire exemption
When the EU ban was first introduced, issues had been particularly raised in regards to the ‘adverse impact’ on Northern Eire, because the UK nation with the very best proportion of crammed enamel.
Beneath publish Brexit preparations, Northern Eire was anticipated to section out dental amalgam on the identical foundation as EU member states.
Nonetheless, six months later, the European Fee permitted an exemption for Northern Eire from the amalgam ban. This got here as an incredible aid to dental leaders, after a survey discovered that 92% of dentists in Northern Eire had been on monitor to scale back the quantity of NHS exercise at their follow within the occasion of a ban.
As well as, 92% mentioned it could improve prices for NHS exercise at their follow, and 91% reported it could affect on greater wants sufferers seen at their follow. An additional 88% mentioned it could lead their follow to scale back or finish its NHS dedication.
The exemption implies that Northern Eire dentists can proceed to make use of dental amalgam till 31 December 2034 – except an earlier date is agreed on by the worldwide Minamata Conference.
Ban ‘could have spelled the end for NHS dentistry’
Ciara Gallagher is chair of the BDA’s Northern Eire dental follow committee. She mentioned: ‘A ban on dental amalgam in 2025 might have spelled the tip for NHS dentistry in Northern Eire.
‘We sounded the alarm and fought tooth and nail for a workable resolution. This delay is a glimmer of hope for a service that’s on its knees and couldn’t have shouldered any additional monetary stress.’
She continued: ‘We now have some respiratory house, however Stormont and Westminster can not take their toes off the pedal to have an effect on a seamless transition to amalgam-free dentistry.
‘Any progress would require reform, funding, and concerted motion on deep oral well being inequalities.
‘When the plug is finally pulled on amalgam, Northern Ireland will need to have a healthier population and a more sustainable service. Otherwise, this 10-year derogation is a mere stay of execution for NHS dentistry.’
The DHSC acknowledged: ‘On account of constructive work between the UK Authorities and the EU, the EU printed a discover that recognises the distinctive circumstances of Northern Eire and the representations made by the UK Authorities.
‘It sets out a specific set of arrangements for Northern Ireland, providing an additional ten years to still use amalgam fillings, or until any earlier time is agreed by the Minamata Convention, to which the UK is a party.’
It added: ‘The ban on EU dental amalgam in Northern Ireland should not affect NHS patients in Northern Ireland being able to get dental treatment when they need it.’
How will the EU amalgam ban affect UK commerce?
Whereas the EU amalgam ban doesn’t have an effect on the UK, the BDA warns that the nation faces disruption and better prices because of the affect on provide chains.
Each Dentsply Sirona and Kerr ceased manufacturing of dental amalgam following the FDA’s (US Meals and Drug Administration) warning in 2020 that sure teams could also be at higher danger of well being results from the mercury vapor launched from dental amalgam.
The FDA mentioned: ‘Our reviews and discussions have generally arrived at the same conclusion: while the majority of evidence suggests exposure to mercury vapor from dental amalgam fillings doesn’t result in dangerous well being results for most individuals, there could also be some results in individuals with sure well being points reminiscent of those that are hypersensitive to mercury.
‘Uncertainties remain about: the effects that long-term exposure to dental amalgam may have on the specific high-risk groups we’ve listed above, the potential for mercury in dental amalgam to transform to different mercury compounds within the physique, and whether or not the buildup of mercury in some physique fluids and tissues ends in different unintended well being outcomes.’
The teams the FDA discovered to be at a higher danger embody:
Pregnant ladies and their creating foetuses
Girls who’re planning to develop into pregnant
Nursing ladies and their newborns and infants
Youngsters, particularly these youthful than six years of age
Individuals with pre-existing neurological illness reminiscent of a number of sclerosis, Alzheimer’s illness or Parkinson’s illness
Individuals with impaired kidney perform
Individuals with recognized heightened sensitivity (allergy) to mercury or different elements of dental amalgam.
SDI to stop dental amalgam manufacture
Southern Dental Industries Restricted (SDI) is presently one of many world’s main producers of dental amalgam. This yr, the corporate informed buyers that it plans to stop manufacturing of dental amalgam by round 2028. This begs the query of what number of different producers will observe go well with, and the affect this might have on UK dentistry.
Samantha Cheetham is SDI CEO and managing director. When requested the corporate’s plans to stop its dental amalgam manufacturing, she informed Dentistry: ‘SDI is dedicated to pioneering dental science and driving innovation in oral well being. A brand new manufacturing website is presently being constructed and we’ve made the strategic resolution discontinue our amalgam manufacturing once we transfer in 2028.
‘Nonetheless, we’re very devoted to making sure UK dentists won’t have any disruption to provide of amalgam. Whereas using dental amalgam is declining, there are some populations and dental conditions the place amalgam is the one attainable therapy. The precedence for each stakeholder should first be oral well being for everybody.
‘We totally help the EU’s latest resolution to ban dental amalgam for many conditions. Whereas amalgam has traditionally performed a significant position in restorative dentistry because of its energy and ease of use – one thing our founder, Jeff Cheetham, championed – fashionable dentistry is evolving past these supplies. The EU ban just isn’t for each nation and each state of affairs, and amalgam shall be used when a dentist sees there isn’t any various.
‘The quantity of mercury utilized in amalgams is extraordinarily low in comparison with different sources. The best atmospheric mercury air pollution comes from coal-fired energy crops, whereas the most important air pollution sources to waterways are from mining operations.
‘The introduction of Stela, our modern amalgam alternative, is a testomony to 50 years of experience. Stela mirrors amalgam’s energy and ease however aligns with the values of minimal intervention dentistry, providing a extra sustainable and patient-friendly possibility.
‘We recognise that though the EU ban doesn’t apply to the UK, it might however affect the demand from dentists as they search for options. We may also present Stela, a superior various to help this transition.’
Dental amalgam ‘should no longer be used’
Florian Schulze is administrative vice-president of the World Alliance for Mercury-free Dentistry and managing director of the European Community for Environmental Drugs, campaigning for a global phase-out of dental amalgam.
Following SDI’s announcement, he mentioned: ‘There are just a few producers left that produce amalgam and the quantity is consistently shrinking. Greater than 60 nations have already phased out its use and the UK might observe quickly.
‘When producers cease making a product to guard the general public, it ought to now not be utilized by public well being providers for remedies. Within the EU, using dental amalgam shall be banned from 1 January 2025 and public reimbursement programs began to switch it with options which can be accessible, efficient and inexpensive.
‘There are just a few producers left that produce amalgam and the quantity is consistently shrinking’
He continues: ‘So as to not be left behind, the UK ought to section out amalgam use as effectively. Dental amalgam is the most important remaining use of mercury and primarily answerable for mercury emissions to wastewater. The federal government won’t obtain its legally binding targets for water well being, which requires water our bodies to attain good ecological standing by 22 December 2027, with out ending using dental amalgam.
‘Factoring in the environmental costs, dental amalgam is more expensive than most, if not all, other filling materials.’
Discover out extra about all the present producers of amalgam right here.
Is the UK following go well with?
Because the EU strikes in the direction of a full ban on dental amalgam, the UK’s place stays one in all a ‘phase down’ of the filling materials.
Whether or not the UK follows go well with will rely on the end result of the sixth assembly of the Convention of the Events (COP 6) to the Minamata Conference on Mercury, a global treaty centered on lowering mercury air pollution globally.
The Minamata Conference, signed by over 150 nations, encourages the discount of mercury use because of its dangerous affect to well being and the surroundings.
The UK’s ‘section down’ method has been in place since 2017 when the Minamata Conference first entered into power.
The BDA states: ‘The UK dental occupation has a longstanding dedication to environmental duty and the BDA agrees with the UK place and the measures set out by the Minamata Conference.
‘We consider that the section down of dental amalgam, at a price acceptable for every signatory nation, to be the best choice for public well being, notably contemplating the pressure on healthcare programs particularly in gentle of the profound affect of the COVID-19 pandemic and the chance of additional exacerbating inequalities.’
As a consequence of happen in Geneva, Switzerland from 3 to 7 November 2025, COP 6 will see member nations, together with the UK, talk about updates to insurance policies on mercury.
Choices made at this assembly might affect the UK’s future rules on dental amalgam, doubtlessly paving the way in which for a whole ban. For now, nevertheless, the UK maintains its present ‘phase-down’ method, with no quick plans to implement an outright ban on amalgam use.
Observe Dentistry.co.uk on Instagram to maintain up with all the newest dental information and developments.